Time Cut, a 2024 science fiction slasher on Netflix, directed by Hannah MacPherson and co-written with Michael Kennedy, has sparked mixed reactions from audiences. Set in 2003, the film follows Lucy, played by Madison Bailey, who accidentally time travels to save her sister Summer (Antonia Gentry) from a masked killer. While it has generated some excitement for its unique blend of genres and nostalgic 2000s setting, viewers have had varied responses, particularly regarding its handling of time travel and slasher elements.
For some, Time Cut falls short in its approach to time travel. A recurring critique highlights that the movie delves into the mechanics of time travel only briefly, treating it more like a punchline than a plot anchor. According to some viewers, this decision leaves a series of unanswered questions and missed opportunities, creating a “whole lot of ‘what ifs’ and not a lot of ‘then whats.'” For those who value consistent storytelling, the movie’s approach to time travel and its apparent lack of a detailed follow-through made it feel underwhelming, even confusing.
Other viewers, however, felt that Time Cut dwelled too much on the science of time travel, detracting from its main purpose as a horror film. These fans noted that a movie with a slasher premise should prioritize suspense and action over scientific accuracy. Instead, some scenes came across as too focused on the complexities of time manipulation, slowing the film’s pace and detracting from classic slasher thrills. Some went as far as to call the plot “cliché and awful,” adding that the twists were uninspired and the ending lacked clarity, leaving them unsatisfied.
Still, there’s praise from fans who appreciate the film’s unique flavor. Those who enjoyed Time Cut found it refreshingly original in its ability to combine horror, science fiction, and a throwback to early 2000s culture. With an engaging soundtrack, well-executed casting, and twists that may be predictable but remain entertaining, the film stood out for its boldness. Supporters argue that Time Cut did not rely on genre conventions from previous horror and sci-fi films, making it feel fresh in its homage to both genres. For them, it’s a memorable, enjoyable watch—an “amazing” movie with a unique take on the slasher trope and time travel fantasy.